
So I stopped by Sears earlier, as one of the few places in town that sells new rims (since I need at least one, preferably a matched set, of replacement wheels on my truck.) Their estimate for new rims pretty much matching my current set ($86/ea), tires of the same line ($85/ea) and assorted labor (alignment, balancing, etc) totaled about $500.
I also checked UPS.com and discovered that it would be cheap to have my dad mail the extra wheel that's at home (came with the truck)--$15-$30, with the more expensive being 3-day Air. And this for a large, heavy tire!
Then called home, talked with dad, and decided the best course of action would be to try to settle outside of insurance with this guy (who, though apparently a nice guy, seems to be having issues with his insurance--like, possibly not having any) and left him a message to that effect.
Of course, there's the hard-line course of action if he delays more and/or refuses to pay damages.. namely, threatening to call the State Trooper back up and indicate that this guy lied about his insurance coverage, since insurance is absolutely required to drive a vehicle, with penalties including fines, forfeiture of registration, and suspension of license, depending on the severity of the transgression.
Fun, eh?
Never got a call back from Visioneer customer service, either. Punks.